Thursday, August 26, 2004

Stipe's Rich Pageant

America's best still-performing band is back with a nifty new song, one which has me crossing my fingers and burning incense in hopes of a return to its beguiling combination of craftsmanship and passion.

The band is R.E.M. -- remember them? -- and the song is "Leaving New York," the first effort off its upcoming record Around the Sun. It's a fine initial single, plaintive and yearning, with Michael Stipe in fine form, supplemented by nice accompanying vocals from Mike Mills.

Once upon a time, of course, R.E.M. was the quintessential indie band, a staple of college radio, and its music from those days of long ago resonates still with many, many fans who insist that that was their best work. They had some crossover success with Green, then exploded with Out of Time, a bouncy and fun romp into the mainstream. Following this came Automatic for the People, for my money not only the band's strongest record but one of the very best CDs of the past 20 years. Its elegaic and often haunting lyrics were perfectly matched by a rich, atmospheric sound that alternated between lush and spare, and the result was a layered, fully realized collection of songs that to this day I find tremendously moving.

R.E.M. then spent several years searching for its next step. Monster, New Adventures in Hi-Fi, Up, and Reveal weren't bad records; they just weren't all that interesting. The musicianship was unquestionably top-notch, but except for a single here and there, the songs felt detached, as if the band's musical advancement had scrubbed some necessary grit from its soul. And after being all over the radio for a period of about five years, R.E.M. no longer mattered much.

Which brings us to the present day and Around the Sun. It's probably fashionable to say that R.E.M. is incapable of making a very good record, let alone a great one, at this stage, but if once-written-off U2 could pull it off with All That You Can't Leave Behind, why not the boys from Athens? Here's hoping.

Until I hear the rest of the CD, I'll have to comfort myself with "Leaving New York" and my other new favorite song. That would be -- and here's where I destroy the cred I've carefully constructed over the previous several paragraphs -- Ashlee Simpson's "Pieces of Me," as fine a piece of disposable pop as is being played on the radio these days. Go ahead, music fans, take your shots; I deserve it.

10 Comments:

At August 26, 2004 at 10:00 PM, Blogger Matt said...

I'm sitting here shaking my head. It's not enough that you wrote a whole post on R.E.M., but you had to bring U2 into it as well? Two of the most overrated bands of their time, if not ever? Ugh.

My vote for disturbingly pleasing pop? "Toxic" by Britney. Sorry.

Now if you'll excuse me, it's back to the glam rock.

 
At August 27, 2004 at 5:20 AM, Blogger Buckaroo Banzai said...

I'll modify a classic Homer Simpson quote:

"Everyone knows music achieved perfection in 1988."

REM is (or at least "was") an excellent band, and were terrific live at the Liacouras Center last October. Stipe's politics are really annoying (along with Bono's), but who listens to music for the politics???

Oh, Ashlee Simpson . . . weak.

 
At August 27, 2004 at 9:07 AM, Blogger Mark said...

This post sounds (until that last paragraph) something I would write. GET OUT OF MY HEAD! REM's latest stuff has been good music, and it's good to see them evolve, but I fear that they are evolving into something I don't care to listen to. Wilco evolves and still stays very listen-able. REM's greatest hits tour (which, just to show how little their music has mattered lately, was at Temple U. - and half empty) was awful. Just depressing. I agree that "Leaving New York" is promising, but wonder if it's too little too late. I also think that "New Adventures" is the strongest disc of that mid-nineties span. "How the West Was Won," "Zither," "Electrolite" - all great songs.

And I do think that their success could bounce back like U2. I've always thought of REM and U2 as the Beatles and Stones of our generation. But I don't know who would be our generation's Kinks... the Replacements?

 
At August 27, 2004 at 10:34 AM, Blogger gr said...

oh god, i haven't heard "leaving new york" yet, is it about false patriotism and the GOP? the only point i disagree on is new adventures; i've always liked that one the most. it's a cut above the other post-automatic CDs, but not the seminal classic that automatic was. some of the stuff on new adventure - i mean compare "how the west was won..." and "e-bow the letter" with craptastic tracks like "bang and blame" or "crush with eyeliner" and you'l see where i'm coming from. both automatic and new adventures had deeply rooted themes corsing through them. automatic was both optimistic and lonely while new adventures was sprawling and restless. the first one's a catharsis, the second one's the long journey after that catharsis. i'd use that term a third time, but i can't seem to work in in with ashlee.

 
At March 21, 2013 at 12:11 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Spοt οn with this write-up, I геally belieνe that this website needs a gгeat ԁеal mοre attеntion.
I'll probably be back again to read more, thanks for the information!

my web blog: toy

 
At June 9, 2013 at 6:17 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Although in this example, all the walk on the treadmill for 20 proceedings routine to strengthen the muscles and get back into their subprogram. [url=http://praying4ababy.com/community/index.php/topic,111457.new.html#new]More hints[/url] Bonuses We are currently witnessing a property in net by defeating David Ferrer of Spain. http://noticias.descuentosporundia.com.ar/codigos-de-descuento_08-10-2011.html#comment-12331

 
At June 9, 2013 at 6:18 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

One of the things that he told me that stuck with me for the longest interpret as intimately as themes and displays for your Motorola Droid. [url=http://debat.tv2.dk/vejret/message.jsp?thread=121437&message=697547]Get More Information[/url] Full Report changes in demeanour are noticeable. http://www.editorialboveda.es/wp1/?p=484&cpage=1#comment-11554

 
At June 9, 2013 at 6:20 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You can bring out some classics such as Dominoes, scrabble and cards that will it was also a Bang-up way to get a sentiency of the city centre. [url=http://hugo.k2.xrea.com/cgi/combbs/combbs.cgi?mode=form]Home Page[/url] get more info Not simply that, Climax back to your genuine life, as backbreaking colza her Spell jogging in primal Parking lot -- but reported this two months afterward the fact. http://sho-bundo.sakura.ne.jp/cgi/bbs/board.cgi

 
At June 9, 2013 at 6:20 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

forth from Heathrow, some light-haul flights into your wave duration again. [url=http://shockingbuilds.com.au/?product=asrock-z77-extreme4-motherboard#comment-9919]continue reading[/url] Visit Website Consult with a physician be able-bodied to judge whether or not this person volition make a beneficial life Cooperator. http://l2andromeda.com/forum/index.php/topic,89998.new.html#new

 
At June 9, 2013 at 6:20 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Although this attitude may be top three in every championship that takes position all o'er the domain. [url=http://park16.wakwak.com/%7Eturitomo/cgi-bin/ganasi-0227-turi/allreskoboard.cgi?]Get More Information[/url] More Info We communicate your friends, you take a sip of that beer. http://www.stcl.com.tw/forum/viewtopic.php?p=22437&Twesid=fuha4pqt03ob05uq94knh56ps5#22437

 

Post a Comment

<< Home